Theory of Change
How Utah Civic Compact aims to rebuild civic participation in Utah, from the neighborhood up.
The compact between Utahns and their government holds when residents trust each other and government answers to them.
Utah Civic Compact aims to rebuild participation from the neighborhood up
Utah Civic Compact works on both halves. We are building low-barrier community that gives people a reason to know each other, and we hold government to account in public so residents can see that taking part changes outcomes.
UCC's agenda is meant to come from Utahns, which requires far more of them to take part. Community produces local leaders who understand how decisions get made and share that with their neighbors. Those neighbors become more likely to vote and to stay involved between elections. Every UCC program, current or planned, serves a step in that process.
Roughly half a million eligible Utahns are unregistered or inactive
As of April 6, 2026, Utah had 1,770,136 active registered voters and 307,635 inactive ones, according to the Lieutenant Governor's office. An inactive voter is one who has missed two regular general elections and did not answer a notice from the county clerk. Counting eligible Utahns who never registered, KSL estimated in October 2024 that more than 508,000 were either unregistered or inactive.
Utah's turnout is strong in presidential years and weak in every other election. In 2024, 85.27 percent of ballots mailed to Utah's 1.8 million registered voters came back. In the 2022 midterm, 52.8 percent of eligible citizens voted, according to the Census Bureau, and the Utah Foundation found that municipal turnout averaged 14 percent from 2017 to 2023.
Municipal turnout is lowest in the urban counties. In 2025, Salt Lake and Utah counties drew 23 and 22 percent of registered voters, while rural Piute and Garfield counties passed 60 percent.
Most nonvoters say their vote does not matter
The Knight Foundation's 100 Million Project surveyed 12,000 Americans who chronically do not vote. Common reasons included disliking the candidates and feeling their vote does not matter. Many said they did not feel informed enough to choose, and barriers to voting ranked lowest among their reasons.
In Utah, the Utah Foundation points to the shortage of competitive races and the complexity of the caucus and convention system. It found that policy alone cannot easily fix most of what keeps Utahns home.
Young Utahns are the least represented. Utahns aged 18 to 29 make up 25.5 percent of the state's voting-age population but were 12 percent of its voters in the 2022 midterm, according to Census figures reported by KUER. A Utah Foundation analyst has tied that gap to how long it takes young people to put down roots in a community.
Community events reach Utahns that political events miss
About one in two American adults reported loneliness in recent years, according to the U.S. Surgeon General's 2023 advisory on social connection. The same advisory found that more connected communities fare better on civic engagement. Utah still ranks first in the nation on the Utah Foundation's 2025 Social Capital Index and first or second on social trust, but its score has been sliding since 2013.
UCC's community events ask nothing political of the people who attend. People who come to help their neighbors meet each other in the process. A political event mostly draws people who already care about the issue, while a community event built around a shared need also draws people who have stopped participating. Those are the Utahns UCC most needs to reach.
In the United Kingdom, a study of first-time voters found that volunteering raised later turnout most among young people raised in politically disengaged households.
Neighborhood leaders turn relationships into civic knowledge
Sidney Verba, Kay Lehman Schlozman and Henry Brady found that the communication and organizing skills behind political activity are built in nonpolitical settings such as workplaces and churches. Residents who organize community events build the same skills, and their neighbors already trust them.
UCC teaches those leaders how a city council or county commission makes decisions and how to tell when one that affects their street is coming. Leaders who want to go further can learn from UCC to speak at a hearing and to organize their own neighborhoods.
Knight Foundation researchers found that nonvoters tend to come across news by accident rather than seek it out, and local leaders put civic information in front of them. Hahrie Han's study of civic associations found that the most active groups develop leaders first, and that this depth lets them reach far more people later.
A first vote makes the next one more likely
In a field experiment with 25,200 registered voters, Alan Gerber, Donald Green and Ron Shachar found that people encouraged to vote in 1998 were also more likely to vote in the 1999 local elections. The effect of having voted before outweighed the effects of age and education.
Voting also spreads inside a home. In David Nickerson's canvassing experiments, 60 percent of the increase in one resident's likelihood of voting passed to the other person in the household.
Helping a Utahn cast a first vote, especially in a low-turnout local election, raises the odds that the person keeps voting and that someone else in the household does too.
Residents stay involved when they can see participation change outcomes
Utahns have less information about local government than they once did. Danny Hayes and Jennifer Lawless found that coverage of local politics in 121 newspapers fell 56 percent between 1999 and 2017. As that coverage shrank, fewer Americans knew who their local officials were and turnout in local elections dropped.
UCC works to close that gap. We request government records under Utah's open records law and publish what they show, so residents can see decisions that would otherwise go unreported. UCC's registered lobbyists carry residents' concerns to the Legislature and to city and county bodies. Press coverage of that work tells more Utahns how a decision was made and who made it.
Trust between neighbors and trust in local government reinforce each other. A two-wave panel study in Sweden found that community trust predicted later trust in local institutions, and the reverse held as well. A 2026 systematic review found that responsiveness is the governance practice most consistently tied to trust in local government.
A resident who has met neighbors and learned how decisions get made, then sees a public body change course after residents spoke up, has a reason to stay involved. Community builds trust between residents, and accountability keeps government responsive to them.
Time with neighbors who vote differently lowers hostility and moderates views
UCC is nonpartisan, and its community events are among the few places where Utahns of both parties show up for the same reason. A 2006 meta-analysis of 515 studies by Thomas Pettigrew and Linda Tropp found that contact between groups typically reduces prejudice, including toward members of the other group a participant never met.
Contact works across party lines too. Matthew Levendusky and Dominik Stecula found that hostility toward the other party fell substantially among people who discussed politics with its members, and the effect lasted at least a week. In the America in One Room experiment, more than 500 registered voters who deliberated together for a weekend moved toward the center on policy, and James Fishkin found that the most polarized opinions moved the most.
Contact has to happen in person and in good faith. When Christopher Bail and colleagues paid partisans to follow a Twitter account sharing the other side's views for a month, Republicans became more conservative. The effects of in-person contact also fade without repetition, so UCC's community events are meant to recur. David Broockman, Joshua Kalla and Sean Westwood found that lower hostility does not by itself change support for democratic norms, and UCC makes no claim that it does.
Connected neighborhoods produce more than voters
Across 148 studies, Julianne Holt-Lunstad and colleagues found that people with stronger social relationships had a 50 percent higher likelihood of survival. Robert Sampson linked neighborhood cohesion in Chicago to lower rates of homicide, and Daniel Aldrich found that communities with strong social networks recovered faster after disasters.
Utah already has the trust this work needs
Utah starts with an advantage most states lack. It ranks first in the nation on the Utah Foundation's Social Capital Index, so the relationships this work depends on already exist in many neighborhoods. Turnout in local elections shows how little of that trust reaches public life.
The compact
UCC exists to connect the two, by bringing neighbors together and by holding our government accountable where residents can see the results. Those are the two halves of the compact UCC is named for.
Sources
- Utah Lieutenant Governor, Current Voter Registration Statistics
- KFF, from the Census Bureau's Current Population Survey: voter registration and turnout by state
- KSL, More Utahns are registered to vote in 2024 compared to 2023
- Salt Lake Tribune, 2024 Utah turnout
- Utah Foundation, Utah County municipal elections
- KSL NewsRadio, 2025 municipal turnout
- Knight Foundation, The 100 Million Project
- Philadelphia Inquirer on the Knight study
- KUER, Why Don't Utahns Vote? It's Complicated
- KUER, We asked 2 young Utah voters why their peers are turned off by politics
- KUTV, Utahns under 40 are half the population, but only a third of its voters
- American Bar Association summary of the Surgeon General's 2023 advisory
- Utah Foundation, Social Capital Index 2025
- Volunteering and first-time voter turnout in the United Kingdom (Cambridge Core)
- Brady, Verba and Schlozman, Beyond SES (APSR 1995)
- Commons Library on Han, How Organizations Develop Activists
- Gerber, Green and Shachar, Voting May Be Habit-Forming
- Nickerson, Is Voting Contagious?
- Hayes and Lawless, News Hole: The Demise of Local Journalism and Political Engagement
- Rebuild Local News, research summary including the Hayes and Lawless coverage figures
- Local Government Studies, community trust and local institutional trust in Sweden
- Systematic review of governance practices and trust in local government
- Pettigrew and Tropp, A meta-analytic test of intergroup contact theory
- Levendusky and Stecula, We Need to Talk
- Fishkin et al., Is Deliberation an Antidote to Extreme Partisan Polarization?
- Bail et al., Exposure to opposing views on social media can increase political polarization
- Broockman, Kalla and Westwood, Does Affective Polarization Undermine Democratic Norms or Accountability?
- Holt-Lunstad et al., Social Relationships and Mortality Risk
- Sampson, Raudenbush and Earls, Neighborhoods and Violent Crime
- Aldrich, Building Resilience