UDOT licensed a plate reader vendor without any authority in state law

Utah law allows UDOT to issue plate reader permits on state highways to law enforcement agencies. UDOT's rule for those permits also requires the agency's vendor to sign its own agreement with UDOT, and under that rule UDOT gave Flock Safety a statewide license in 2024.

Utah Civic Compact November 16, 2026 By Jarom Gillins, Director of Policy

No statute authorizes UDOT to license a vendor. We are asking Gov. Spencer Cox to direct UDOT to pause vendor-owned cameras on state highways until the Legislature passes regulations for them.

What brought us here

In August we released Weber County records showing that 10 Flock cameras authorized by the county had been searched more than 5 million times since February 2022, almost all of those searches by agencies outside Utah. Gov. Cox said he was "deeply troubled," noted that Utah already has laws on these cameras, and said "the question is, is the legislation being followed?"

In October we asked UDOT to end its license agreement with Flock under a clause that allows termination when the public does not support the company's activities, and we opened a petition. UDOT said it was reviewing whether the cameras had proper permits. We then looked at whether UDOT had the authority to sign the agreement at all.

The statute gives the permit to a law enforcement agency

S.B. 250, passed in 2023 and sponsored by Sen. Daniel McCay, requires a law enforcement agency to obtain a special use permit from UDOT before installing a plate reader aimed at a state highway. Utah Code 72-1-212 defines that permit as one issued "to a law enforcement agency to install an automatic license plate reader on a state highway," requires UDOT's rules to be "not inconsistent with this chapter," and assigns responsibility for the camera to the agency.

Utah Code

"For a device installed in accordance with Section 41-6a-2003, the installation, maintenance, data collection, and removal are the responsibility of the law enforcement agency that obtains the special use permit."

— Utah Code 72-1-212(8)

We think the Legislature got this right. The statute makes the agency that holds the permit accountable for the camera.

UDOT's rule requires a separate agreement with the vendor

UDOT adopted its rule for these permits, R920-4-16, in November 2023. Subsection (6) provides that a contractor may only perform work under a permit "after the contractor or agent executes, and maintains compliance with, an authorized provider agreement" with UDOT, and UDOT's permit page tells contractors they "must enter into a License Agreement with UDOT prior to application for encroachment permits."

UDOT's agreement with Flock, Agreement No. 258065, took effect . It grants the company a license to conduct "ALPRS Operations" statewide, "regardless of which LEA has contracted for the Company's services." We obtained the agreement through a public records request and have posted it below.

Flock owns the cameras. Its website says the company "leases its cameras and manages installation, maintenance and removal," the same duties the statute assigns to the agency that holds the permit.

No statute gives UDOT the power to license a vendor

The statute provides for a permit to a law enforcement agency and says nothing about vendors. The Utah Supreme Court has held that an agency "can only assert those [powers] which are expressly granted or clearly implied," and that "any reasonable doubt of the existence of any power must be resolved against the exercise thereof" (Williams v. Public Service Commission, 1988).

Our position

UDOT could not create a vendor license by rule where the statute provides none, and a camera owned and operated by a vendor under its own statewide license is not the permit holder's installation.

The Legislature has not reviewed whether the rule is authorized

The Legislature's rules committee is required to examine each agency rule to determine "whether the agency rule is authorized by statute." UDOT published this rule as a proposal on , and it took effect . The committee met once in that period, on November 13, and the rule was not on the agenda. We found no record that the committee has examined it since. UDOT presented the rule to the Personal Privacy Oversight Commission on November 8, 2023, and that presentation described permits for police agencies without mentioning vendor licenses.

The rule has been reauthorized each year in the bill that reauthorizes every state rule. State law provides that reauthorization "does not constitute legislative approval of the rule."

What we are asking for

Gov. Cox: pause the vendor cameras until the Legislature acts

The governor appoints UDOT's executive director. We are asking him to direct UDOT to pause vendor-owned plate reader cameras in the state highway right-of-way until the Legislature passes regulations governing them. This would not revoke any police agency's permit. Utah Code 72-7-104 already allows UDOT to remove installations in a highway right-of-way that do not comply with the transportation code, so a pause is a smaller step than the law permits. Flock says it can deactivate its cameras remotely.

General Oversight Committee: review the rule before the 2027 session

On November 5 we asked the committee to put R920-4-16 on an agenda before the 2027 General Session, ask UDOT which statute authorizes the vendor provisions, and request every license agreement UDOT has signed under the rule.

We are updating our petition to ask the governor to act.

What the Legislature should decide

If vendors are going to be part of plate reader systems on state highways, the Legislature should set the terms in statute, with the agency responsible for every camera and no vendor license the law does not provide for. The Utah Privacy Commission's task force has recommended that agencies own and control the data their systems collect and that vendors process it only on the agency's behalf. Utah's law on government use of plate readers is among the strongest in the country, and those recommendations would extend it to the systems agencies now buy.

Sources